ietf-nntp OVER response code 420: 2 cases

Wilbert de Graaf wilbertdg at hetnet.nl
Tue Apr 16 16:42:16 PDT 2002


In the draft-ietf-nntpext-base-15.txt the response codes for OVER are defined
as:

    224 Overview information follows (multi-line
        response)
    412 No newsgroup currently selected
    420 No article(s) selected
    500 Command not recognized
    502 Program error, functions no performed

The text says that 420 should also be used when the articles/overview in the
range specified are not available. I wondered if a code like 421 would be more
in line with the ARTICLE/NEXT/... commands. They use the xx0 to indicate
'article not selected', and set the last digit to something <> 0 to indicate a
valid number. The examples use 420 for both cases:

420 No such article in this group
420 No current article selected

Would it not be more consistent to add 421 or so to indicate that there are not
articles in the range requested ?

Thanks, Wilbert




More information about the ietf-nntp mailing list