ietf-nntp NNTP AUTH draft update

Andrew Gierth andrew at erlenstar.demon.co.uk
Tue Nov 9 14:56:29 PST 1999


>>>>> "Chris" == Chris Newman <chris.newman at INNOSOFT.COM> writes:

 Chris> Compliant clients MUST issue "LIST EXTENSIONS" prior to using
 Chris> "AUTHINFO".

This still leaves the problem of existing noncompliant clients that
issue LIST EXTENSIONS anyway.

 Chris> If the "LIST EXTENSIONS" command fails, clients MAY attempt to
 Chris> use "AUTHINFO USER"/"AUTHINFO PASS" but should be aware that
 Chris> the server is likely to use x8x response codes in that case.

More importantly, they should be aware that the server is likely to
give a 480 response to signal 'authentication required for command'.
It is of course also possible that the client will get a 480 response
to the LIST EXTENSIONS itself....

Obviously a compliant server will have to allow LIST EXTENSIONS even
if the client has not yet authenticated... this is a complication,
albeit a very minor one, as the other forms of LIST command will
generally be restricted to authenticated clients.

-- 
Andrew.



More information about the ietf-nntp mailing list