Review: Network Effect, by Martha Wells
eagle at eyrie.org
Tue Jun 16 21:24:07 PDT 2020
by Martha Wells
Series: Murderbot Diaries #5
Copyright: May 2020
Network Effect is the first Murderbot novel, although the fifth story
of the series. The previous stories, beginning with All Systems Red,
were novellas. Under no circumstances should you start reading the
series here. Network Effect builds significantly on the story arc that
ended with Exit Strategy and resolves some important loose ends from
Artificial Condition. It's meant to be read in series order.
I believe this is the first time in my life that I've started reading a
book on the night of its release. I was looking forward to this novel
that much, and it does not disappoint.
I'll try not to spoil the previous books too much in this review, but
at this point it's a challenge. Just go read them. They're great.
The big question I had about the first Murderbot novel was how would it
change the plot dynamic of the series. All of the novellas followed
roughly the same plot structure: Murderbot would encounter some humans
who need help, somewhat grudgingly help them while pursuing its own
agenda, snark heavily about human behavior in the process, once again
prove its competence, and do a little bit of processing of its feelings
and a lot of avoiding them. This formula works great at short length.
Would Wells change it at novel length, or if not, would it get tedious
The answer is that Wells added in quite a bit more emotional processing
and relationship management to flesh out the core of the book and
created a plot with more layers and complexity than the novella plots,
and the whole construction works wonderfully. This is exactly the book
I was hoping for when I heard there would be a Murderbot novel. If you
like the series, you'll like this, and should feel free to read it now
without reading the rest of the review.
Overse added, "Just remember you're not alone here."
I never know what to say to that. I am actually alone in my head,
and that's where 90 plus percent of my problems are.
Many of the loose ends in the novellas were tied up in the final one,
Exit Strategy. The biggest one that wasn't, at least in my opinion, was
ART, the research transport who helped Murderbot considerably in
Artificial Condition and clearly was more than it appeared to be. That
is exactly the loose end that Wells resolves here, to great effect. I
liked the dynamic between ART and Murderbot before, but it's so much
better with an audience to riff off of (and yet better still when there
are two audiences, one who already knew Murderbot and one who already
knew ART). I like ART almost as much as Murderbot, and that's saying a
The emotional loose end of the whole series has been how Murderbot will
decide to interact with other humans. I think that's not quite resolved
by the end of the novel, but we and Murderbot have both learned
considerably more. The novellas, except for the first, are mostly solo
missions even when Murderbot is protecting clients. This is something
more complicated; the interpersonal dynamics hearken back to the first
novella and then go much deeper, particularly in the story-justified
flashbacks. Wells uses Murderbot's irritated avoidance to keep some
emotional dynamics underplayed and indirect, letting the reader
discover them at opportune moments, and this worked beautifully for me.
And Murderbot's dynamic with Amena is just wonderful, mostly because of
how smart, matter-of-fact, trusting, and perceptive Amena is.
That's one place where the novel length helps: Wells has more room to
expand the characterization of characters other than Murderbot,
something that's usually limited in the novellas to a character or two.
And these characters are great. Murderbot is clearly the center of the
story, but the other characters aren't just furniture for it to react
to. They have their own story arcs, they're thoughtful, they learn, and
it's a delight to watch them slot Murderbot into various roles, change
their minds, adjust, and occasionally surprise it in quite touching
ways, all through Murderbot's eyes.
Thiago had said he felt like he should apologize and talk to me more
about it. Ratthi had said, "I think you should let it go for a
while, at least until we get ourselves out of this situation.
SecUnit is a very private person, it doesn't like to discuss its
This is why Ratthi is my friend.
I have some minor quibbles. The targetSomething naming convention
Murderbot comes up with and then is stuck with because it develops too
much momentum is entertaining but confusing. A few of the action
sequences were just a little on the long side; I find the emotional
processing much more interesting. There's also an subplot with a
character with memory holes and confusion that I thought dragged on too
long, mostly because I found the character intensely irritating for
some reason. But these are just quibbles. Network Effect is on par with
the best of the novellas that precede it, and that's a high bar indeed.
In this series, Wells has merged the long-running science fiction
thread of artificial intelligences and the humanity of robots with the
sarcastic and introspective first-person narration of urban fantasy,
gotten the internal sensation of emotional avoidance note-perfect
without making it irritating (that's some deep magic right there), and
added in some top-tier negotiation of friendship and relationships
without losing the action and excitement of a great action movie. It's
a truly impressive feat and the novel is the best installment so far. I
will be stunned if Network Effect doesn't make most of the award lists
Followed by Fugitive Telemetry, due out in April of 2021. You can
believe that I have already preordered it.
Rating: 9 out of 10
Russ Allbery (eagle at eyrie.org) <https://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/>
More information about the book-reviews