Review: Caliban's War, by James S.A. Corey

Russ Allbery eagle at eyrie.org
Wed Mar 27 20:45:21 PDT 2019


Caliban's War
by James S.A. Corey

Series:    The Expanse #2
Publisher: Orbit
Copyright: June 2012
ISBN:      0-316-20227-4
Format:    Kindle
Pages:     594

Caliban's War is the sequel to Leviathan Wakes and the second book in
the Expanse series. This is the sort of series that has an
over-arching, long-term plot line with major developments in each book,
so it's unfortunately easy to be spoiled by reading anything about
later volumes of the series. (I'm usually reasonably good at avoiding
spoilers, but still know a bit more than I want about subsequent
developments.) I'm going to try to keep this review relatively free of
spoilers, but even discussion of characters gives a few things away. If
you want to stay entirely unspoiled, you may not want to read this.

Also, as that probably makes obvious, there's little point in reading
this series out of order, although the authors do a reasonably good job
filling in the events of the previous book. (James S.A. Corey is a
pseudonym for the writing team of Daniel Abraham and Ty Franck.) I
still resorted to reading the Wikipedia plot summary, though, since it
had been years since I read the first book.

Caliban's War opens on Ganymede, a year and a half after the events of
Leviathan Wakes. Thanks to its magnetosphere, Ganymede enjoys rare
protection from Jupiter's radiation field. Thanks to
meticulously-engineered solar arrays, it is the bread basket of the
outer solar system. That's before an inhuman creature attacks a unit of
Earth and then Martian soldiers, killing all but one of them and
sparking an orbital battle between Mars and Earth that destroys much of
Ganymede's fragile human ecosystem. Ganymede's collapse is the first
problem: a humanitarian catastrophe. The second problem is the
attacking creature, which may be a new destabilizing weapon and may be
some new twist on the threat of Leviathan Wakes. And the third problem
is Venus, where incomprehensible things are happening that casually
violate the known laws of physics.

James Holden returns to play a similar role as he did in Leviathan
Wakes: the excessively idealistic pain in the ass who tends to blow
open everyone's carefully-managed political machinations.
Unfortunately, I think this worked much less well in this book. Holden
has a crisis of conscience and spends rather a lot of the book being
whiny and angstful, which I found more irritating than entertaining. I
think it was an attempt at showing some deeper nuance in his
relationships with his crew, but it didn't work for me.

The new character around whom the plot revolves is Prax, a botanist
whose daughter is mysteriously kidnapped in the prelude of the book.
(Apparently it can't be an Expanse novel without a kidnapped girl or
woman.) He's unfortunately more of a plot device than a person for most
of the story. One complaint I have about this about this book is that
the opening chapters on Ganymede drag on for much longer than I'd
prefer, while running Prax through the wringer and not revealing much
about the plot. This is another nearly 600 page book; I think it would
have been a tighter, sharper book if it were shorter.

That said, the other two new viewpoint characters, Bobbie and
Avasarala, make up for a lot.

Avasarala is an apparently undistinguished member of the UN Earth
government who has rather more power than her position indicates
because she's extremely good at political maneuvering. I loved her
within twenty pages of when she was introduced, and kept being
delighted by her for the whole book. One of my favorite tropes in
fiction is watching highly competent people be highly competent, and
it's even better when they have engagingly blunt personalities.
Avasarala is by turns grandmotherly and ruthless, polite and
foul-mouthed, and grumpy and kind. Even on her own, she's great; when
she crosses paths with Bobbie, the one surviving Martian marine from
the initial attack who gets tangled in the resulting politics,
something wonderful happens. Bobbie's principled and straightforward
honesty is the perfect foil for Avasarala's strategic politics. Those
sections are by far the best part of this book.

I think this is a somewhat weaker book than Leviathan Wakes. It starts
slow and bogs down a bit in the middle with Holden's angst and
relationship problems. But Avasarala is wonderful and makes everything
better and gets plenty of viewpoint chapters, as does Bobbie who
becomes both a lens through which to see more of Avasarala and a
believable and sympathetic character in her own right. The main plot of
the series does move forward somewhat, but this feels like mostly side
story and stage setting. If you enjoyed Leviathan Wakes, though, I
think you'll enjoy this, for Avasarala and Bobbie if nothing else.

Caliban's War satisfactorily closes out its own plot arc, but it
introduces a substantial cliff-hanger in the last pages as setup for
the next book in the series.

Followed by Abaddon's Gate in the novel sense. There is a novella, Gods
of Risk, set between this book and Abaddon's Gate, but it's optional
reading.

Rating: 7 out of 10

Reviewed: 2019-03-27

-- 
Russ Allbery (eagle at eyrie.org)              <http://www.eyrie.org/~eagle/>


More information about the book-reviews mailing list